When it comes to buying an electric smoker there are two important factors that will ultimately decide on which one to choose and which one to ignore. The first are the features such as the quality of smoke, design, durability, ease of use, assembly and temperature management system.
The second most important factor is the price of the smoker and the budgetary constraints. Although there are tons of high end electric smokers readily available in the market, most folks prefer the budget smoker that gives them the ultimate value for money.
Keeping the above two essential factors in mind let’s explore the best electric smokers out there and determine which one is the best electric smoker under 200.
Top 5 Best Electric Smokers Under 200
1. Char-Broil Analog Electric Smoker
Like other signature smokers of Char–Broil this is another masterpiece which gets the job done every single time. As the name suggests this is an analog smoker with no digital controls or integration with any smart devices whatsoever. The traditionalists would not mind that one bit since it frees them from dealing with unexpected issues and errors that sometime grip the digital system. Being an analog smoker the readings are reliable and consistent. Char-Broil offers this item with one year warranty so there is an added peace of mind while buying this model.
This electric smoker is sturdy and made to last. Durability is the stand out feature of this model. The real estate this smoker takes up is sizeable with 544 sq inches in total. The smoker does not have a window glass display which is largely insignificant if the user is experienced in using electric smokers.
A wonderful feature about this device is the big wood chip box. The large size is a great advantage since the user does not have to refill the box every hour while smoking is in progress. Fewer refills means a hassle free experience. Design wise the smoker is spot on especially when it comes to placement of the analog thermometer which is mounted on the front door. The device is equipped with a water pan made from aluminized steel that guarantees longevity. Also present is a drip tray to ensure easy cleaning of the smoker. The insulation is of top class standard and encircles the cooking chamber. For mobility there are two side handles given as well.
2. Old Smokey Electric Smoker
When it comes to budgetary constraints, this product is one of the best electric smokers available today and has been around since 1953. The smoker has a fairly large cooking space with 14.5” in diameter and comes with a total of two grills. Since the grills have handles they are fairly easy to remove or insert. The grills are divided in to upper and lower section with the upper grill having a diameter of 14.5”. The upper grill is equipped with an additional grill. The lower one is located at the first cooking level and is slightly smaller at a diameter of 12.5”.
On first glance this device gives an impression that the heating capacity might not be great since the heating element resembles those of an electric oven. That lack of heating power is countered by its capacity for effective insulation. The system is controlled digitally and is variable. This allows tremendous leeway when it comes to temperature and cooking time.
Temperature gauges have to be ordered separately but are inexpensive so it is highly recommended to get them in tandem with the smoker. Just above the heating element the wood chip tray is located for filling up variety of wood chips. The top is flat and is sealed tightly during the cooking process. This has multiple advantages. Firstly the flavors and smoke are locked in tightly and the juices that evaporate fall right back in on the food. The result is a juicy flavorful barbecue every single time. Having said that, when the electric smoker is not being used be sure to take the lid off to eliminate any moisture that may be present inside.
3. Smoke Hollow 26142E Electric Smoker
A serious contender for the title of best electric smoker under 200 this model from the legendary brand Smoke Hollow gives the other electric smokers a good run for their money. It has a solid construction with a sturdy built and is one of the most affordable smokers in the market. Design wise, this model is tailor made for the barbecue enthusiasts who love experimenting with various blends of juice and wood flavors. Another segment among which 261142E is popular is with folks that have just started using electric smokers for the very first time. Since the price is relatively lower this smoker gives buyer a good idea whether they would be interested in smoking meats for the long haul or not. If yes, then they will invariably upgrade after a while.
The first impression a user gets from this particular model is how basic it is. The smoker is not equipped with window glass display or chimneys. The model doesn’t have a digital control system either. This however does not make this electric smoker any less functional. In fact the electric smoker reviews suggest that the results this device generates are excellent.
When it comes to the cooking space the model is 26’ high and has 14 x 12 cooking trays which are coated with chrome. The smoker is not meant for bigger gatherings. Noteworthy features are the adjustable temperature controls. 26142E model has a 1500 watt heating element with maximum temperature of 325° F and minimum of 175° F. This gives the user, end to end control over the cooking process depending on their preference.
Cleaning is a breeze since the pans are made from porcelain. The wood chip tray is also made from porcelain which gives the user room to experiment with different kinds of wood chips.
4. Landmann MCO 32954 Smoky Mountain
There is an array of budget smokers in the market but the best electric smoker will always differentiate itself from the pack by having stand out features that makes it a firm favorite. Among these, the Landmann MCO 32954 holds a special place. The best feature about the device is how compact it is. This makes it well suited for folks that have limited space but love smoking outdoors. The total area occupied is 443 sq inches. Considerable space is saved by giving 3 in 1 combination features (water pan, grease pan and the wood chip box).
The smoker is equipped with a glass window display which makes the entire cooking process hassle free. Progress can be monitored by simply viewing instead of probing manually with a thermometer. The manual probing is a major source of losing smoke and heat. Temperature gauge is placed intelligently on the door for optimum control of temperature. Furthermore, the smoking chamber is designed brilliantly to retain heat and smoke. The magnetic door closure further ensures there is no leakage and the flavors stay intact.
The cooking capacity for this model is excellent as suggested by electric smoker reviews and contains three chrome plated grates which are easy to clean. Mobility is also strength for this smoker since its lightweight and is fitted with iron handles on the side for easy maneuverability. In addition, since the electric smoker has adjustable feet it can stand easily on any uneven surface without any problems.
5. Smokehouse Big Chief Front Load Smoker
For big gatherings and outdoor parties The Big Chief Front Load Smoker is a winner. The smoker with five grills allows cooking of meats in bulk ranging from twenty five to fifty pounds. The cooking is based purely on electric power alone. The smoker is custom made for outdoor usage only. The solid construction is a powerful feature of this device laced with embossed aluminum for protection and longevity. It comes with a 2 year warranty that adds to its reliability. The smoker does not require assembly which is a cumbersome task on its own. This is why it is such a popular choice for over 5 decades and is still one of the best electric smokers to date.
To help you get started the model comes with an instruction manual and smokehouse recipe. With that also comes a bag of 1.75 pounds of wood chips (hickory flavor). The heating element is of 450 watt and is non adjustable by nature. The heating element maintains 165° F for the purpose of slow cooking. There has been a special emphasis on smoke circulation and smoke ventilation on the Front Load Smoker. The result is deliciously smoked meat with the perfect texture. Like other popular electric smokers, the grills are plated with chrome and can be easily loaded and unloaded quite similar to that of an oven. As the name suggests the meats are loaded from the front. At the base of the smoker is a drip pan which prevents mess and makes cleaning a straightforward task.
Upon reviewing the above five best electric smokers, there is tight competition between two of them. One is the Char-Broil Analog and the other one is Old Smokey. If we compare both of these head to head they are dead even in terms of important features and price point. Therefore we have to look at other factors such as ease of use, reliability and capacity. If we keep the above three considerations in mind Char-Broil Analog Electric Smoker edges out the Old Smokey Electric Smoker by thinnest of margins and claims its rightful spot as the best electric smoker under 200.
If you are looking for more Electric Smoker Reviews do read our Top 10 Best Picks